Captain’s Anchorage Review – Big Bear Lake, CA

For many locals and long-time visitors, Captain’s Anchorage isn’t just a place to eat — it’s part of Big Bear Lake’s dining history. Known for its classic steakhouse menu, fresh seafood, and old-school atmosphere, Captain’s Anchorage is a go-to restaurant for celebrations, special occasions, and anyone who appreciates consistency and tradition.



This is one of those rare places in Big Bear where you know exactly what you’re getting — and that’s a big reason it remains so popular year after year.

Overview

Captain’s Anchorage has been a staple in Big Bear Lake for decades and is especially popular with locals, part-timers, and visitors celebrating birthdays or special occasions. It’s often mentioned among the best steakhouses in town, not because it’s trendy, but because it’s reliable.



One of the biggest practical advantages? Captain’s Anchorage takes and honors reservations, which is surprisingly uncommon in Big Bear Lake. Reservations can be made directly through their website and are highly recommended on busy weekends.

Atmosphere & Setting

The building itself looks like an older mountain cabin, and the interior leans into that classic, old-school steakhouse feel. It’s intentionally darker inside, giving the space a cozy, traditional vibe that feels right at home in a mountain town.

There are three main dining areas:

• The bar area – a favorite for regulars and those who enjoy a lively, social atmosphere
• The lower dining room – traditional and comfortable
• Upstairs dining – often more livelier and a great option for a relaxed meal

There’s also an additional upstairs room used at times, and during the summer months, a new outdoor patio opens up, often featuring live music. The patio is a great change of pace and adds a more upbeat, seasonal feel to the experience.

Service & Staff

One of the standout features of Captain’s Anchorage is its long-tenured staff. This is a place where you’ll start to recognize familiar faces over time, which says a lot about both the restaurant and the experience.

The bar is especially well known thanks to Lorraine, a longtime bartender and local favorite. She’s part of the restaurant’s personality and a big reason many regulars prefer sitting at the bar.



Service overall is professional, consistent, and attentive — exactly what you want in a classic steakhouse.

Food & Menu Highlights

Captain’s Anchorage offers a traditional steakhouse menu, featuring appetizers, steaks, and an impressive selection of fresh seafood — something they take pride in, even being located in a mountain town.

A great way to start the meal is with the artichoke appetizer, a newer addition that’s become a favorite. Pair it with a Patty’s Pomegranate Martini, and you’re off to a strong start.

Standout Entrées

• Pan-seared salmon – flavorful, perfectly cooked, with a nicely crisped top
• Filet mignon – consistently cooked to temperature and one of the most reliable choices on the menu

Entrées come with a side salad and your choice of potato. The baked potato, served with fixings on the side, is a classic and consistently done just right.

Captain’s Anchorage is also well known for:

• Prime rib
• Lobster
• Crab legs

All solid choices if you’re looking for a traditional steakhouse experience.

Desserts follow the steakhouse theme, with familiar favorites rounding out the meal. One of the most talked-about is the Shipwreck dessert, a longtime menu staple that many guests order specifically to share.

Service

Captain’s Anchorage is often mentioned when people talk about haunted places in Big Bear Lake. While the restaurant doesn’t lean heavily into this theme, it’s part of the local lore and adds a bit of intrigue to the building’s long history.

Whether or not you believe in ghost stories, the history is undeniable — and it’s part of what gives the restaurant its character.

You can read more about the haunted history of the Captain's Anchorage in our Article Does a Ghost Haunt a Local Big Bear Restaurant?

Good to Know Before You Go

• Best for: Special occasions, birthdays, steak and seafood lovers
• Reservations: Accepted and honored (highly recommended)
• Seating tips: Bar seating or upstairs dining are favorites
• Busy times: Weekends, holidays, celebration dinners
• Summer bonus: Patio seating with live music

Overall Impression

Captain’s Anchorage is one of the most dependable restaurants in Big Bear Lake. The food is consistently good, the service is polished, and the atmosphere feels timeless.

You may not find experimental dishes or modern trends here — but what you will find is a restaurant that delivers the same quality experience every time.

For anyone looking for a classic steakhouse, a reliable celebration spot, or a place that truly feels like part of Big Bear Lake’s history, Captain’s Anchorage remains a top choice.

If you’re comparing steakhouse options in town, you can also explore our top steakhouses in Big Bear Lake guide to see how Captain’s Anchorage compares with other local favorites.