Best Steakhouses in Big Bear Lake

If you’re craving a great steak dinner in Big Bear Lake, you’re in luck — this mountain town has several standout restaurants that serve everything from classic prime rib to modern wood-grilled cuts. Whether you prefer the rustic charm of a historic lodge, the upscale feel of a fine-dining restaurant, or a lively spot with craft cocktails and live music, Big Bear offers something for every kind of steak lover.

Here are our top picks for the best steakhouses and steak dinners in Big Bear Lake — starting with long-time local favorite Captain’s Anchorage, followed by Peppercorn Grille and Oakside.

Location: 42148 Moonridge Rd, Big Bear Lake, CA

Located in the Moonridge area just off Big Bear Blvd, Captain’s Anchorage is a true Big Bear landmark and one of the town’s longest-running restaurants. The rustic log-cabin exterior and historic interior give it an authentic mountain-lodge feel — cozy, warm, and full of character.

Inside, you’ll find two distinct dining experiences: the lower-level dining room near the bar and the upstairs main dining area. Downstairs, the bar area has a welcoming, old-school vibe, where longtime bartender Lorraine is known for greeting guests like locals and keeping the atmosphere friendly and relaxed. Upstairs, the dining room offers a more classic steakhouse setting, perfect for a sit-down dinner. In warmer months, guests can also enjoy a seasonal outdoor patio with live music — a newer addition that adds a fun, social touch.

The menu centers around traditional steakhouse favorites, including a 24 ounce porterhouse, New York strip, and filet mignon, all cooked to perfection. The seafood is fresh and well-prepared, with options like fresh salmon, shrimp, seabass and lobster rounding out the menu. Every dish is consistently delicious, and the service is known for being attentive and professional without feeling rushed.

Adding to its lore, Captain’s Anchorage is rumored to be haunted by “George,” a friendly ghost said to linger from the restaurant’s early days in the 1940s. Staff and guests alike have shared stories of unexplained sounds and flickering lights — just enough mystery to make your dinner even more memorable. If this has your attention, just ask one of the staff as they love to share stories or you can also join one of their new haunted dinner experiences.

Steeped in history and mountain charm, Captain’s Anchorage remains one of Big Bear’s most reliable spots for a hearty, satisfying meal — a perfect blend of tradition, great food, and friendly service that keeps both visitors and locals coming back year after year.

Captain's is only open for Dinner.

Make a reservation at Captains Anchorage

Location: 553 Pine Knot Ave, Big Bear Lake, CA

Right in the heart of The Village, Peppercorn Grille is one of Big Bear Lake’s most loved spots for a nice dinner. The moment you step inside, it feels cozy and welcoming — warm lighting, stone accents, and a mountain-lodge elegance that strikes just the right balance between upscale and comfortable. On sunny afternoons or summer evenings, the patio is a great place to relax, sip a glass of wine, and watch the bustle of The Village go by.

The menu has something for everyone, but their steaks are always a standout — especially the angus filet mignon, bone-in ribeye, and angus New York strip. You’ll also find fresh seafood, hearty pasta dishes, creative appetizers, and delicious dinner salads. Peppercorn Grille also has a surprisingly extensive wine list, making it a great choice for wine lovers who appreciate a well-paired glass with dinner.Everything here is beautifully presented and consistently good, which is why so many locals recommend it for special occasions or date nights.

Service is another thing Peppercorn does exceptionally well. The staff is professional yet friendly, making guests feel taken care of without the stuffiness that sometimes comes with fine dining.

If you’re looking for a place that delivers great food, great service, and a polished mountain-town atmosphere, Peppercorn Grille should definitely be on your Big Bear lunch or dinner list.

Make a reservation at Peppercorn Grille

Location: 40701 Village Dr, Big Bear Lake, CA

If you’re looking for a lively place with great food and a fun atmosphere, Oakside is the spot. Located right in The Village, Oakside combines modern mountain style with an easygoing vibe that works just as well for a casual night out as it does for a special dinner. The two-story layout features wood, stone, and glass throughout, giving it a bright, open feel. Downstairs, you’ll find a large patio with a fire pit — perfect for enjoying a drink under the mountain sky. Upstairs, you'll find a more casual bar area, great for having a drink before dinner.

Oakside’s menu is broad but well-crafted, offering everything from steaks, seafood and burgers to hearty salads, pizzas, pastas and shareable appetizers. The bone-in ribeye and skirt steak are favorites among locals, and the portions are generous. The bar is one of the best in town, with craft cocktails, local beers, and live music on weekends, adding to the fun energy.

Service here is upbeat and friendly, and the whole place has a relaxed, social feel — it’s where you’ll often find groups gathering after a day on the slopes or couples enjoying a casual date night.

With great food, a lively atmosphere, and one of the best bar scenes in Big Bear, Oakside is a top choice for anyone looking to unwind and enjoy a night out in the mountains.