Sister My Sister Bake Shop

Overview

Sister My Sister Bake Shop is a longtime local bakery in Big Bear Lake known for homemade baked goods, desserts and specialty treats that feel more personal and homemade than a traditional commercial bakery. The shop has built a loyal following among both locals and visitors looking for pastries, desserts and coffee while spending time in Big Bear. The atmosphere is casual and cozy with very limited seating, making it more of a quick stop bakery and café rather than a full sit-down restaurant experience.

the Food

The bakery is especially known for its desserts, bread pudding, cinnamon rolls, pies, pastries and custom baked goods. Holiday pies are one of the biggest seasonal favorites and often become part of visitors’ cabin traditions during Thanksgiving and Christmas trips. In addition to coffee and espresso drinks, the shop also sells unbaked cinnamon rolls that guests can take back to their cabins and bake fresh in the morning, which has become a popular option for vacation stays and family weekends.

Things to Know

Sister My Sister is especially busy during holiday weekends and pie-ordering seasons, when many visitors stop in specifically for specialty desserts and custom baked goods. The shop is also well known for custom cakes and advance holiday pie orders. Seating inside is fairly limited, so many guests grab pastries and coffee to go while exploring The Village. The unbaked cinnamon rolls are one of the more unique offerings in town and are especially popular with visitors staying in cabins who want a fresh breakfast experience without cooking from scratch.